He created the series on his own initiative, almost in secret. Realizing the period's absolute repression, he kept the series hidden until his death in 1863, when it came to light and received its final title.
The gallery's accompanying commentary encouraged viewers to consider that Goya was asking us to keep looking at the unspeakable tragedies when we would prefer to look away. Think of it as the ethics of a witness and contemplating the pain of others.
About 600 women and children died just in the siege of Zaragoza, and Goya brought to light the civilians' desire to fight, the moments of insurgency at the height of the struggle. We could feel the fierce onslaughts, the energy, fury, and panic.
People died in agony, and corpses were tossed into the street, stacked in piles beside churches, in piles like straw dolls, as the French banned burials. Human forms were lost as they merged with the earth, decomposed, and remained unburied for a long time. Goya showed that period cloaked in darkness.
Goya's series juxtaposed with Iberia, a large abstract canvas by American expressionist Robert Motherwell, painted after his 1958 trip to Spain, when he was profoundly moved by what he found in Goya's Black Paintings. I found it hard, though, to wrap my head around the sharp contrast with the explicit violence in Goya's living narrative and the abstract contemplation of Motherwell's painting. I had to stretch my mind to see any connection beyond the black ink and black oil paint the artists used.
Motherwell was inspired by the hidden violence and the grim reality of the Franco dictatorship. To him, black symbolized war's tragic condition. Goya expressed the vividness of war in his famous phrase about his war series: "I saw it." Mothwell seemed to say, "You have to be here."
I was never so glad to get out in the open of the cloister, see the bright blue sky, and feel the sun's warmth after that death and darkness.
Then it was back inside, to the church's monumental space in the original convent, to view The Sert Canvases, eleven exceptional varnish-on-metal paintings by Spanish artist José María Sert, 1874-1945. When the building was restored in 1929, and the convent was considered for repurposing as a museum, it was recommended that the church walls be covered with paintings of the most important events in Basque history. Sert was commissioned to represent the life and history of its people.
To get just a sense of the paintings' magnitude and celebration of the Basques, click on the images to enlarge them!
A People of Wisdom showed one of the most significant moments in Basque history: the Real Sociedad Bascongade de Amigos del Pais, or the Basque Society of Friends of the Country, Spain's first enlightened society. The image showed scientists conducting research, and chemists discussing a product.
The A People of Explorers canvas was dedicated to the epic poem by Basque native Juan Sebastián Elcano, and illustrated the dramatic moments explorers went through.
We had never seen a people's history detailed in art, let alone on such a grand scale. Other equally spellbinding canvases portrayed Basque shipowners, fishermen, merchants, saints, and blacksmiths.
We couldn't forget the space had been a former church with the tomb and former confessionals.
The Traces of Spirituality Gallery featured stelae, or funerary markers, as the Basque people have held rites revolving around ancestor worship for centuries. Stelae in cemeteries, funeral candle holders, and along paths have continued to the present day.
Some carvings included the name of the deceased with a reference to the family crest or home to symbolize the connection between home and grave.
Memory Traces: Although the oldest evidence of human presence in the Basque Country dates to more than 150,000 years ago, to the Lower Paleolithic Period, most prolific remains come from later prehistoric eras. UNESCO has declared some cave paintings in the Basque region to be World Heritage Sites.
Images from the gallery:
Examples of 17th-century iron aldaba, or doorknockers and trim:
A necklace from the Upper Paleolithic Period was believed to reveal an aesthetic sentiment!
The Tithe Chest: During the Middle Ages, only the church guaranteed both temporary and eternal protection, with peasants providing one tenth, or diezmo, of their farming and livestock to the clergy.
These most unusual long-pronged pitchforks were more practical on slopes and suited the wet, Atlantic soil.
Cloth headdresses worn by married and widowed women in the Basque Country indicated not only their marital status, but also their place of origin and economic status. After they were interpreted as phallic symbols in the early 17th century, ecclesiastical authorities banned them!
The Spanish Civil War was experienced differently in the Basque Country than in the rest of Spain because it was mainly seen as a war between Catholics with different political beliefs. That was accentuated when the Spanish Basque region was further divided into two distinct areas.
José Luis Zumeta’s portrayal of a tree trunk around 1976 formed the basis of a poster, 24 Hours in Basque, for the first time after it was in a private collection.
Basque society began a rapid period of modernization in the 1980s, marked by changes in gender roles, demographic trends, and secularization. These changes became more pronounced in the 1990s.
On the right were chisteras, or woven wicker baskets used in Basque pelota, one of the fastest ball games in the world, with record speeds exceeding 300 km/h! Players hit a ball against a wall or across a net/line using their bare hand, a wooden paddle, a racket, or a chistera. In the U.S., pelota is known as jai alai.
Without a doubt, the Sert canvases were the highlight of the museum for me, though the disturbing Goya engravings came in a very close second.
In the previous post on San Sebastián, I mentioned that its doors weren't as attention-grabbing as many in Bilbao, our first stop in Spain's Basque Country. However, these two doors did make me stop and look twice!
After a full and very fun day in San Sebastián, we crossed back over the city's lovely Maria Christina Bridge to pick up our bags at the bus station and go to our apartment.
As always so interesting. Headdresses…phallic symbols?!
ReplyDeleteWho'd ever have thought, Lynne!
DeleteWhat a haunting collection by Goya; Over 200 years later, his portrayal of the horrors of war remains sadly relevant today. As always , thanks for the tour. xo Lina xo
ReplyDeleteCan we never learn, Lina?! So tragic, isn't it, that history keeps repeating itself? At least Goya was there to chronicle the horrors for future generations. XOXO Annie in Rabat, Morocco
DeleteAlthough our thought about touring the museum was learning more about Basque culture, Lina, Goya's depiction of what he observed was a highlight for us. XOXO Annie
ReplyDeleteI remember studying Goya’s drawings in my 20’s and couldn’t not look at his depictions of violence and inhumanity. Why are such a violent species?.
ReplyDeletePutting Goya aside there is art everywhere in everything in Spain. It’s my next travel destination.
I don't remember his drawings, John, so I was glad we had the chance to view 80 of them in the excellent Basque museum.
ReplyDeleteGlad to hear you're heading to Spain soon. As we know do well, there's no time like the present.